B1ALIVE · CALIFORNIA PLANTS

Prickly sowthistle — glossy spiny leaves and tender tips · Sonchus asper

Sonchus asper

Among California's garden weeds grows a sowthistle with glossy, toothed leaves whose edges carry small but unpleasantly sharp prickles. Later it produces yellow flower heads resembling tiny dandelions. This is Sonchus asper, prickly sowthistle, a close relative of the already described common sowthistle. The most tender young leaves and some peeled tips are known as raw food. Mature prickly foliage is another matter: it is not suitable for an ordinary salad.

Prickly sowthistle (Sonchus asper) — glossy toothed leaves with prickly edges and yellow flower heads
Prickly sowthistle (Sonchus asper) — glossy toothed leaves with prickly edges and yellow flower headsHoosierMan1816 · CC0 · Wikimedia Commons

HOW TO IDENTIFY IT

Usually an annual herb with a basal rosette and an upright, hollow stem. White milky sap emerges if the stem is broken. The lower leaves are large and often deeply lobed, with glossy surfaces and stiff little teeth around the margins. Upper leaves sit directly on the stem without long stalks, clasping it with rounded, ear-like lobes. The glossy, firm leaf blades and rounded auricles at the base of stem leaves are particularly characteristic of the species. In warm, fertile places the plant may grow taller than a meter. Yellow heads of narrow ray florets open at the stem tips. After flowering, achenes with pale windborne hairs form; mature heads look like small fluffy balls. Young leaves can be far softer than mature ones. Identification is therefore best confirmed from neighboring flowering plants of the same species, without mixing different plants in one handful.

WHERE IT GROWS AND HOW COMMON IT IS

UC IPM describes sowthistles as among the most common weeds of California's spring farms and gardens. Sonchus asper is an invasive member of this group. It grows in vegetable beds, along fields, in gardens, on disturbed roadsides and among irrigated plantings. In mild climates, seeds can germinate at unusual times, but most young plants appear after rain. Around agricultural land in the Central Valley, it is especially important to establish whether herbicides have been applied. Dry, hardened foliage on tall summer plants does not have the same food value as damp, young growth.

WHEN THE EDIBLE PARTS ARE AVAILABLE

In lowlands, seeds often germinate from late autumn through early spring. Rosettes bear their most tender leaves from December through March. Flowering stems may develop in early spring in warm locations, while flowering and ripening of the white windborne seed tufts often peak in spring and early summer. Later plants may occur in irrigated places. For raw food, the age of each leaf matters more than the month alone: prickles become increasingly uncomfortable as leaves mature.

Prickly sowthistle (Sonchus asper) — glossy toothed leaves with prickly edges and yellow flower heads
Prickly sowthistle (Sonchus asper) — glossy toothed leaves with prickly edges and yellow flower headsBjoertvedt · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

WHAT IS EATEN WITHOUT FIRE

Very young leaves. Plants For A Future explicitly identifies tender Sonchus asper leaves eaten raw. Their flavor is less harsh while a leaf is still soft and its marginal prickles are undeveloped. Mature spiny leaves cannot be considered equivalent. If a leaf scratches the fingers, it should not go into a raw salad.

Young tender shoot tips. The same species reference describes them eaten raw after coarse portions have been removed. Milky sap in older stems can be bitter, a further reason not to recommend tough flowering stalks as fresh food. Gather this part only after full identification and when every prickly section can be separated.

Roots, mature seeds and the entire adult stem are excluded. Washing and removing dirt are necessary, but simple rinsing does not make chemically treated field plants safe.

HOW NOT TO CONFUSE IT

Common sowthistle, Sonchus oleraceus, generally has duller, softer leaves with more pointed auricles at the base of stem leaves. Sonchus asper leaves are shinier, firmer and more prickly, with rounded auricles. Other yellow-flowered composites also exude white latex. Check leaf shape, leaf base, hollow stem and flower heads together. Do not identify a plant merely from bitter milky sap and one yellow blossom. Gathering greens along agricultural strips and on urban lawns is especially risky because of chemical treatments.

SOURCES