B1ALIVE · CALIFORNIA PLANTS

Prickly Russian thistle — tender green shoots before tumbleweed forms · Salsola tragus

Salsola tragus

In late summer, almost spherical bushes with numerous thin, interwoven branches can be seen on California's dry vacant ground. In autumn some of these plants dry, break off at the base and roll across open plains with the wind. In spring, however, the future “prickly ball” looks completely different: a tender green annual with juicy, slender shoots. Limited raw food use is described only at this early stage.

Prickly Russian thistle (Salsola tragus) — rounded branched tumbleweed with narrow leaves
Prickly Russian thistle (Salsola tragus) — rounded branched tumbleweed with narrow leavesDcrjsr (Jane S. Richardson) · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia Commons

HOW TO IDENTIFY IT

Salsola tragus is an annual herb that may grow into a dense, branching bush approximately 30 centimeters to a meter or more across. Its stems are light green, sometimes marked with reddish stripes. Young leaves are narrow, nearly cylindrical and slightly fleshy; they may feel soft, but as they age the tips of the leaves and bracts harden, becoming sharp and prickly.

The main stem branches early. An adult plant produces a dense network of arching shoots and becomes spherical or hemispherical. Tiny greenish-pink flowers sit in leaf axils rather than resembling familiar large-petaled flowers. As fruit matures, the perianth parts expand into thin, translucent wings, sometimes pinkish. When the aboveground mass dries, branches can break away from the roots and carry seeds with the wind.

There is an important botanical difficulty with this name. Salsola tragus, S. australis and S. ryanii occur in California and look extremely similar. Their differences include the dimensions of flowers and other reproductive structures. At the young, green stage, it may be impossible to identify the exact species reliably.

Prickly Russian thistle (Salsola tragus) — rounded branched tumbleweed with narrow leaves
Prickly Russian thistle (Salsola tragus) — rounded branched tumbleweed with narrow leavesForest & Kim Starr · CC BY 3.0 us · Wikimedia Commons

WHERE IT GROWS AND HOW COMMON IT IS

Russian thistle is not a forest green but a plant of open, dry places. In California, members of this group are common in sandy and loose soils, on pastures, abandoned fields, disturbed roadsides and desert valleys. UC IPM describes them throughout the state, particularly in the south, up to elevations of approximately 2,700 meters.

A single large tumbleweed may produce an enormous number of seeds, allowing numerous seedlings to emerge on loose, open ground. However, the plant is especially characteristic of already disturbed soil. Such places are often unsuitable for collecting fresh greens: roadsides and agricultural land may be contaminated with herbicides or runoff.

WHEN THE EDIBLE PARTS ARE AVAILABLE

Spring. After germination, slender juicy leaves and soft green tips appear. This stage may be short in hot lowlands.

Early summer. The plant branches actively, but some shoots remain tender. Hard tips begin to develop as it grows.

Summer and autumn. Small flowers and fruits develop, and the bush quickly becomes prickly. This stage is no longer suitable for eating green shoots.

Autumn and winter. The dry ball disperses its seeds, but the tumbleweed itself is not a food part for a no-fire diet.

WHAT IS EATEN WITHOUT FIRE

The very youngest leaves and shoot tips. The USDA NRCS species guide for Salsola tragus explicitly describes young tips eaten raw. Before prickles develop they are soft and juicy, sometimes slightly salty. Traditional food accounts describe them as a small addition to fresh greens.

Raw Russian thistle shoots cannot be considered a reliable, permanent food supply. Depending on soil and growing conditions, the plant may accumulate nitrates and soluble oxalates. Studies have found substantial variation in concentrations among samples; a tender-looking shoot reveals nothing about its nitrate or oxalate content. Another difficulty is the resemblance of several species at the early stage. Therefore, on a journey without the ability to identify the species precisely and assess the growing conditions, these shoots are unsuitable as a practical gathering recommendation.

Mature tough leaves, stems, fruits and seeds are not included as raw food: there is no reliable basis for presenting them as convenient ready-to-eat food without processing.

HOW NOT TO CONFUSE IT

Salsola australis and Salsola ryanii form similarly branching bushes; distinguishing features often become visible only at flowering and fruiting. It is therefore a mistake to label any green seedling “edible Salsola tragus.”

Other drought-tolerant plants may have narrow, fleshy leaves or a round habit. A mature tumbleweed must be assessed by branching, flowers and fruits, yet those mature features appear after the period of soft green food has ended. This mismatch between the eating season and the time of reliable identification substantially reduces the plant's practical value for raw gathering.

SOURCES