B1ALIVE · CALIFORNIA PLANTS

Sugar pine — the Sierra's longest cones and edible raw seeds · Pinus lambertiana

Pinus lambertiana

High above trails in the Sierra Nevada stand powerful pines with straight, thick trunks and astonishingly long, hanging cones. Some cones look like elongated wooden garlands, and large seeds spill from their opening scales in autumn. This is Pinus lambertiana, sugar pine, one of the tallest pine species in the world. Its mature seeds can be eaten raw. Despite the name, this article is not about sugar or syrup preparation: the practical food eaten without fire is the seed kernel.

Sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) — very long pendant cones and bundles of five needles
Sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) — very long pendant cones and bundles of five needlesRichard Sniezko / US Forest Service Dorena Genetic Resource Center · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

HOW TO IDENTIFY IT

An adult sugar pine can grow several tens of meters tall; old trees develop a very thick, dark-gray trunk. Younger crowns are more regular, while those of older trees are broad and often asymmetric. Needles grow five to a bundle and are relatively slender and softer than the needles of gray pine, generally several centimeters long. Small male pollen cones appear in spring. Female cones develop over two seasons, gradually becoming long, cylindrical, pendulous structures. Some grow thirty to fifty centimeters long or more. Their scales are relatively thin and lack the heavy, sharply curved hooks typical of Coulter pine. Winged seeds develop on the seed-bearing scales. As the mature cone dries, its scales open and the seeds fall. Empty cones from previous years may remain beneath the tree for a long time.

WHERE IT GROWS AND HOW COMMON IT IS

Calflora lists Pinus lambertiana as native to California, with many observations from Placer, El Dorado, Plumas, Tuolumne, Shasta, Siskiyou, Tulare and other mountain counties. For a traveler leaving Sacramento, it is a characteristic tree of the Sierra's mixed-conifer forests above the hot valley. It also occurs in some coastal mountain ranges. The tree favors well-drained slopes and deep forest soils. The US Forest Service emphasizes that good seed crops come from mature trees, while young specimens may produce almost no cones for many years. There can be many empty cones around one old pine in autumn, but rodents and birds usually gather the seeds quickly.

WHEN THE EDIBLE PARTS ARE AVAILABLE

Pollination takes place in spring, before any fresh, mature nuts are available. Large cones develop over two years and change from green to light brown. According to the US Forest Service, seeds may begin dispersing in lower forest zones in late August, while at higher elevations dispersal generally concludes by late October. September and October are therefore the main guide for finding a fresh, mature crop. Some years have poor fruiting, and old hanging cones are no guarantee of viable seeds. Dry seeds left in damp forest litter for too long may spoil.

Sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) — very long pendant cones and bundles of five needles
Sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) — very long pendant cones and bundles of five needlesRichard Sniezko / USDA Forest Service · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

WHAT IS EATEN WITHOUT FIRE

Mature seed kernels. Plants For A Future confirms their raw use. Remove the papery wing from a seed, carefully crack its firm outer shell, and eat the pale kernel inside. The flavor is slightly sweet and nutty, sometimes with a faint resinous note. Kernels can be eaten individually or mashed into an oily mixture without heating. Avoid seeds with musty odors or signs of mold.

What this method does not include. Historically, sweet substances were obtained from sugar pine, but some preparations required water evaporation and therefore cooking with fire. The species reference also cautions that concentrated sweet exudates can have a laxative effect if consumed in large amounts. Do not gather or drink them as an all-purpose syrup. Needles, pollen, bark and young green cones are not included in this raw-food selection.

Even a relatively slender, long cone falling from a tall tree can be dangerous. Never stand directly beneath mature cones, shake the branches or try to knock a cone down from above.

HOW NOT TO CONFUSE IT

Western white pine, Pinus monticola, also has five needles per bundle and can bear elongated cones. Sugar pine cones are usually much longer, and the crown and trunk of an old sugar pine are more massive. Pinus sabiniana and Pinus coulteri usually have three needles per bundle, with shorter, heavy cones bearing thicker scales. A dry cone found far from a tree is not enough for identification; someone may have carried it there. Examine a living branch with five needles, the bark and a mature cone. Do not break open rotten fallen cones in search of doubtful seeds.

SOURCES