In the moist coastal forests of Northern California, a low tree or large shrub is sometimes covered in white flowers during spring.

By autumn, numerous tiny apples appear among the foliage, their colors ranging from yellow to deep red.
This is Malus fusca, the Pacific or Oregon crabapple.
Its fully ripe fruits can be eaten raw, although they are distinctly more sour than cultivated apples. The inner seeds are not food: Calflora explicitly warns against consuming the seeds of this species.

HOW TO IDENTIFY IT
Usually a deciduous shrub or small tree with several trunks, sometimes forming dense coastal thickets.
The branches are flexible and bear many short fruiting spurs on older shoots; some branches may end in thornlike twigs.
Leaves are alternate and stalked, oval or elliptical, with small marginal teeth. On vigorous shoots, leaves may have three shallow lobes.
Young leaves are softer and slightly hairy. Mature leaves are dark green above and paler underneath.
In spring, small five-petaled white, occasionally pinkish flowers appear in short clusters.
After pollination, tiny apple-like fruits form, often slightly elongated and far smaller than supermarket apples.
Their color changes from greenish yellow to red or purple.
Remnants of the flower persist at the fruit tip, and inside are several separate seed chambers with brown seeds.
WHERE IT GROWS AND HOW COMMON IT IS
Calflora recognizes Malus fusca as native to California, with relatively few observations, chiefly from northern coastal wetlands, riparian ground and moist forest.
Oregon State University describes its natural range along the Pacific coast from Alaska to Northern California, often beside creeks, along marsh margins and in woodland.
It is not an ordinary urban wild apple in the Sacramento Valley. Near houses, cultivated Malus domestica or escaped garden seedlings are much more likely.
In suitable places elsewhere along the Pacific coast, Pacific crabapple may form dense thickets, but its natural range within California is relatively narrow.
It is not an orchard crop distributed throughout the state.
WHEN EDIBLE PARTS ARE AVAILABLE
Fresh leaves unfold in early spring.
White or pale pink flowers generally appear in April–May, later in particularly cool northern habitats.
After pollination, small fruits grow for several months, remaining green and hard through summer.
By late summer and autumn, they turn yellowish or reddish and gradually soften.
Plants For A Future notes that the fruit can become less sour after the first autumn cold weather.
In very wet coastal habitats fruit spoils quickly, so an autumn crop is not necessarily available for long even on the same tree.
WHAT CAN BE EATEN WITHOUT COOKING
Fully ripe flesh of the little apples. Plants For A Future directly confirms raw consumption of Malus fusca fruit.
Fruits are small, commonly about one to two centimeters across, with a pronounced tart flavor.
Cut each apple open and eat its fresh flesh after removing the seed-bearing core.
Oregon State University also notes the edibility and sour character of these fruits. They are better suited to a small cold fruit addition than to a large sweet dessert.
Cold mashed pulp. Fully ripe seedless fruit can be mashed and combined with less sour fruit.
This does not require fire, but it quickly browns and spoils without refrigeration.
Calflora explicitly warns of toxic seeds in this species, so do not chew them or grind the core into the pulp. Seeds of other Malus species may also contain cyanogenic compounds.
Leaves, bark, young shoots and seeds are not included as raw foods.
Never gather fruit from sprayed trees or from contaminated marsh water.
HOW TO AVOID CONFUSION
Cultivated apple, Malus domestica, sometimes escapes cultivation and bears small fruit, but differs in its shoot structure, leaves and origin.
Some Pyrus pears resemble little apples, though their flowers and fruit structure differ.
Certain California hawthorns, Crataegus species, also bear miniature apple-like fruit, but often have stronger thorns and more deeply divided leaves.
Malus fusca is especially associated with wet northern coastal habitats, small elongated fruits and many short fruiting spurs.
A single fallen little apple cannot establish the tree's species; examine flowers, leaves and a complete shoot.
SOURCES
Calflora, species: https://www.calflora.org/app/taxon?crn=5350
Plants For A Future, raw ripe fruit: https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Malus+fusca
Oregon State University, Pacific crabapple: https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/malus-fusca
