In northern coastal oak woodland and cool California meadows, tall thistles sometimes stand with purple flower heads grouped at the ends of their shoots. Their leaves are armed with spines, but young plants develop a substantial taproot underground.
.jpg?width=1100)
It is the peeled young root of this particular species that has been eaten raw. Digging it up destroys the plant, however, and large portions may cause severe bloating because of its inulin content.
HOW TO IDENTIFY IT
This is a biennial or short-lived perennial herb, commonly one to two meters tall.
In its first year, it forms a basal rosette of long, lobed leaves, green and only slightly hairy above, sometimes whitish-woolly beneath. Their margins have short, stiff prickles.
In the following growing season, a thick, upright, fleshy stem develops and branches toward its upper part.
Flower heads usually grow in tight groups, sometimes partly surrounded by the upper leaves. Their involucral bracts are covered with thin, cobweb-like hairs. The tubular florets are reddish purple.
After flowering, dry achenes form, each with a long feathery tuft.
WHERE IT GROWS AND HOW COMMON IT IS
Calflora recognizes Cirsium brevistylum as native to California and records hundreds of observations, mainly along the northern and central coast.
It grows in moist meadows, at forest edges, in open parts of mixed evergreen woodland and among coastal shrubs. Extensive natural stands are not to be expected on Sacramento's hot valley floor.
Some older publications used the name Cirsium edule for this California thistle, but modern botanical treatments distinguish the two species.
WHEN EDIBLE PARTS ARE AVAILABLE
In spring, young plants develop their basal leaves, while older ones produce fleshy stems. Flowering usually takes place in summer and may continue longer in cool, damp coastal places.
The taproot stores nutrients before flowering; once a tall flower stalk has developed, the root often becomes more fibrous.
Underground parts may be collected only where gathering is permitted and the species has been identified beyond doubt. To protect local populations, do not dig up successive young plants.
WHAT CAN BE EATEN WITHOUT COOKING
Young taproot. Ethnobotanical accounts from Pacific coastal peoples separately document eating peeled Cirsium brevistylum roots raw.
After digging, remove all soil and the dirty outer skin and use the pale inner tissue while it is still tender.
The root can contain substantial inulin, a carbohydrate not digested directly by humans that often causes gas and abdominal discomfort. Large raw portions are therefore unsuitable.
A peeled young stem is also described as food, but its specifically raw preparation is less unambiguously established; it is not the primary confirmed raw food in this article. Do not eat the spiny leaves or flower-head bracts.
HOW TO AVOID CONFUSION
Cirsium vulgare, discussed elsewhere, has coarse spiny wings running along its stem and large flower heads.
Cirsium arvense grows in perennial patches linked through creeping roots and has smaller flower heads.
True Cirsium edule, distributed chiefly from Oregon northward, is morphologically similar but differs in the flower style and head structure. It is incorrect to apply that name automatically to the California plant.
Digging up a young thistle before seeing its flowers does not guarantee a correct species identification. If in doubt, leave the root undisturbed.
SOURCES
Calflora: https://www.calflora.org/app/taxon?crn=2119
Plants For A Future: https://pfaf.org/USER/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Cirsium+brevistylum
Burke Herbarium: https://burkeherbarium.org/imagecollection/taxon.php?Taxon=Cirsium+brevistylum
