B1ALIVE · CALIFORNIA PLANTS

Redmaids — pink spring flowers, fresh greens and tiny seeds · Calandrinia menziesii

Calandrinia ciliata

In late winter and early spring, small plants with narrow, succulent leaves appear in sunny grasslands of the Sacramento Valley. Bright pink, sometimes crimson, flowers later open above the foliage. This is redmaids, a California plant whose tender young greens were eaten fresh; its tiny dark seeds can also be consumed without heating.

Redmaids (Calandrinia menziesii) — pink flowers and narrow succulent foliage
Redmaids (Calandrinia menziesii) — pink flowers and narrow succulent foliageJoe Decruyenaere (pixeltoo) · CC BY-SA 2.0 · Wikimedia Commons

HOW TO IDENTIFY IT

Redmaids is a low annual herb, usually 10–30 centimeters tall. Several slender green or reddish stems spread from one base. Some shoots lie close to the ground, while others turn upward. Early in the season, a plant may resemble a little rosette of narrow, succulent leaves.

The simple, alternate leaves are relatively narrow, from linear to oblanceolate, generally about 2–8 centimeters long. They are slightly fleshy and smooth, sometimes bearing a few fine hairs at the margins. Each leaf narrows toward the base, resembling a short petiole.

The flowers are comparatively large for such a small plant. They normally have five rounded pink-red petals, sometimes a deeper crimson, with a pale center and visible stamens. They open most fully in good light and may remain closed early in the morning or on cloudy days.

Redmaids (Calandrinia menziesii) — pink flowers and narrow succulent foliage
Redmaids (Calandrinia menziesii) — pink flowers and narrow succulent foliageStickpen · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons

After flowering, a small, elongated capsule develops. It holds many minute, glossy black seeds, usually around one to two millimeters long. Once the capsule ripens, it splits open and scatters its seeds; a plant whose flowers have already faded may therefore have no seeds left to gather.

WHERE IT GROWS AND HOW COMMON IT IS

This species is native to California and occurs elsewhere in western North America. Within California it grows in open grasslands, foothill oak woodland, fields, gardens, vineyards and places where winter moisture remains in the soil.

UC IPM notes that redmaids is particularly abundant in the Sacramento Valley and northern San Joaquin Valley. Around Sacramento it may be seen in open grassy sites after winter rain. It is much less characteristic of the driest deserts and the high eastern slopes of the Sierra Nevada.

Its scientific name requires care. Older ethnobotanical studies and weed references often called it Calandrinia ciliata; the modern Jepson flora of California uses Calandrinia menziesii for the California species discussed here. Both names in the cited California references concern this food plant, but photographs of an unrelated Calandrinia species should not be substituted.

WHEN EDIBLE PARTS ARE AVAILABLE

The first young leaves and stems grow during the cool, moist season, from winter into early spring. At low elevations in California, tender greens can be available roughly January–April, depending strongly on rainfall.

Flowers generally appear February–May. In cooler foothills this may occur later than on sunny valley floors. Seed capsules follow the flowers, and the small seeds ripen during spring and early summer, not all at once.

When sustained heat arrives and the soil dries, the aboveground plant quickly dies back. Unlike an evergreen shrub, redmaids does not supply fresh greens for all twelve months.

WHAT CAN BE EATEN WITHOUT COOKING

Tender young leaves and shoots. They were eaten raw. The USDA NRCS plant guide for redmaids quotes a specific observation by Sparkman from 1908: the Luiseño ate the tender young greens fresh. This concerns a method without cooking, unlike the seed-roasting methods found in other historical accounts. The taste is described as somewhat sharp, reminiscent of arugula. The short season for these greens begins well before the seeds mature.

Ripe black seeds. These seeds are extremely small but contain oil. Plants For A Future specifically lists raw consumption and grinding as possible methods. To gather a supply, separate the tiny mature seeds from dry capsules and remove fragments of the plant. Historical California accounts also describe other processing methods, but only methods without heat are considered here.

The USDA NRCS guide cautions that redmaids greens contain oxalic acid, as spinach does, and should be consumed in moderation. Since the greens are not cooked here, boiling to reduce oxalates is not an option; they should not be recommended in large portions. The pink flowers are helpful identification clues, but no separate reliable species-specific confirmation of raw flower consumption is included in these sources.

HOW TO AVOID CONFUSION

Look for the combination of narrow, slightly fleshy leaves, five pink-red petals and a small capsule filled with glossy black seeds. Some Clarkia species have four petals rather than five. Geranium species commonly have much more deeply divided leaves and elongated, beak-like fruits. Do not identify a young, nonflowering plant solely by the reddish color of its stem.

Modern California references generally use Calandrinia menziesii for redmaids, while older publications and UC IPM may retain Calandrinia ciliata. Examine the leaves, pink five-petaled flower and seed capsule together. An image or description of another Calandrinia species cannot establish the identity of this one.

SOURCES

UC IPM, Redmaids, distribution and season: https://ipm.ucanr.edu/weeds-identification-gallery/redmaids/

Calflora, modern name: https://www.calflora.org/app/taxon?crn=13205

USDA NRCS, Fringed Redmaids Plant Guide, Luiseño food use: https://plants.usda.gov/DocumentLibrary/plantguide/pdf/cs_caci2.pdf

Plants For A Future, Calandrinia ciliata, raw leaves, shoots and seeds: https://pfaf.org/user/Plant.aspx?LatinName=Calandrinia+ciliata

UC Irvine Natural History, flower and seed characters: https://nathistoc.bio.uci.edu/Plants%20of%20Upper%20Newport%20Bay%20(Robert%20De%20Ruff)/Portulacaceae/Calandrinia%20ciliata.htm